Stop Catalina Island deer killing project

The Issue

The Catalina Island Conservancy has initiated a disturbing and controversial project aimed at eradicating the mule deer population from Catalina Island in California. This drastic measure is being carried out with the intention of restoring the island's natural ecosystem, yet it comes with significant ethical and ecological implications that must be reconsidered.

Mule deer have been a part of Catalina Island's wildlife for over 90 years, and their presence has become an integral aspect of the island community's natural heritage and tourist appeals. Eradicating these animals will not only disrupt the island's ecological balance but also diminish its cultural and economic value. Many tourists are drawn to Catalina Island to witness its diverse fauna, including the mule deer, thus supporting local businesses and contributing to the economy.

Instead of resorting to eradication, we urge the Catalina Island Conservancy to consider humane and scientifically backed alternatives such as population control through sterilization or relocation programs. These alternatives can effectively manage the deer population without resorting to inhumane killing, thus preserving the island's biodiversity and respecting animal rights.

Ecosystems are complex networks that have adapted over time to include all their inhabitants. Removing a top grazer such as the mule deer could have unintended consequences, potentially leading to overgrowth of certain plant species and imbalances that could affect other wildlife populations on the island.

It is crucial that we preserve the wildlife that makes Catalina Island unique and reject policies that promote the destruction of life. Join us in calling on the Catalina Island Conservancy to halt the deer eradication project and adopt more compassionate and ecologically responsible methods of wildlife management.

Your signature can make a difference in stopping this inhumane project. Please sign and share this petition to protect the mule deer and preserve Catalina Island's rich natural legacy.

19,005

The Issue

The Catalina Island Conservancy has initiated a disturbing and controversial project aimed at eradicating the mule deer population from Catalina Island in California. This drastic measure is being carried out with the intention of restoring the island's natural ecosystem, yet it comes with significant ethical and ecological implications that must be reconsidered.

Mule deer have been a part of Catalina Island's wildlife for over 90 years, and their presence has become an integral aspect of the island community's natural heritage and tourist appeals. Eradicating these animals will not only disrupt the island's ecological balance but also diminish its cultural and economic value. Many tourists are drawn to Catalina Island to witness its diverse fauna, including the mule deer, thus supporting local businesses and contributing to the economy.

Instead of resorting to eradication, we urge the Catalina Island Conservancy to consider humane and scientifically backed alternatives such as population control through sterilization or relocation programs. These alternatives can effectively manage the deer population without resorting to inhumane killing, thus preserving the island's biodiversity and respecting animal rights.

Ecosystems are complex networks that have adapted over time to include all their inhabitants. Removing a top grazer such as the mule deer could have unintended consequences, potentially leading to overgrowth of certain plant species and imbalances that could affect other wildlife populations on the island.

It is crucial that we preserve the wildlife that makes Catalina Island unique and reject policies that promote the destruction of life. Join us in calling on the Catalina Island Conservancy to halt the deer eradication project and adopt more compassionate and ecologically responsible methods of wildlife management.

Your signature can make a difference in stopping this inhumane project. Please sign and share this petition to protect the mule deer and preserve Catalina Island's rich natural legacy.
291 people signed today

19,005


The Decision Makers

Catalina Island Conservancy
Catalina Island Conservancy

Supporter Voices

Petition updates

Share this petition

Petition created on February 4, 2026