Torsion Analysis of Circular Shafts
Torsion Analysis of Circular Shafts
MATERIALS
(MECH 206)
F. Javidrad
Spring 2024
Middle East Technical University
North Cyprus Campus
Some parts of the course materials have been taken from the following references.
2
Chapter-5
Torsion of circular shafts
3
General
General
■ In this chapter we analyze torsion of circular shafts. The term torsion refers to a
deformation produced by twisting moments. Twisting moments also refer to moments that
its vector senses along the axis of the shaft (Fig. 1).
Fig . 1
dT dF .r (4.1)
The summation of forces for all elements at the cross
section would be
T r dF (4.2)
Fig . 5.3
Circular shafts in torsion (Cont’d)
■ Since the partial force dF is equal to the shear stress t in the element dA, we can write
T rt dA (4.3)
■ It is noted that the shear stress t in equation 4.3 cannot only occur in one plane and the
condition of static equilibrium enforces that equal shear stresses exist in perpendicular
planes.
Fig . 4
Circular shafts in torsion (Cont’d)
■ Consider a shaft with one end fixed and carrying a twisting moment T at the other end. The
free end rotated by the angle f as shown in Fig. 5. This angle is called the angle of twist.
It can be imagined that the angle of twist is primarily a
function of the applied torque T, and the length of the
shaft, L. However, because of the symmetry of the
circular cross-section, in torsion of circular shafts, it is
assumed that all thin disks of the shaft rotate as a rigid
body without any distortion (warping) (Fig. 6).
This implies that
every cross section of
the shaft remain
planar after
deformation.
Fig . 5 Fig . 5
Circular shafts in torsion (Cont’d)
According to the assumption of deformation in the torsion of
circular shafts, the shear strain along the shafts can be
determined. By considering Fig. 7, if we look at the
deformation of a small square during torsion, it is seen that the
square tends to be a rhombus. The angle of shear strain can be
related to the angle of twist by the following relation.
L rf (4.4)
rf
(4.5)
L
It is seen that the shear strain is directly related to r. So the
maximum shear strain occurs at the maximum r which is c.
cf
max (4.6)
L
Fig . 7
Circular shafts in torsion (Cont’d)
■ Eliminating f between Eq. (4.5) and (4.6) gives
r
max (4.7)
c
■ Eq. 4.7 shows that the shear strain has a linear distribution in the circular cross-section. It
is zero at the center of the circle and linearly increases with radius. It becomes maximum
at the maximum radius which is c.
4.2. Stresses in the elastic range
There are many experimental indications that, in the elastic region, the shear stress is related
to the shear strain by a material property called the modulus of rigidity (G) (or the “shear
modulus of elasticity”).
t G (4.8)
Using this relation, Eq. 4.7 can be re-written as
Stresses in the elastic range (Cont’d)
r
t t max (4.9)
c
Equation (4.9) shows that there is a linear distribution in shear stress along any radius from
the center of the circle of the cross-section. This would be true for both solid or hollow cross
sections (Fig. 8).
In a hollow shaft, the minimum shear strain occurs
at the periphery of the inner circle and the
maximum shear stress at the outer circle periphery.
Fig .10
Stresses in the elastic range (Cont’d)
■ Another case of using shafts in practice is the stepped shafts that may carry
different twisting moments at each portion. In such cases, the polar moment of
inertia and the twisting moment can be different in every section. So, to find
shear stress in each section, it is enough the draw the free-body diagram of the
shaft and determine the twisting moment at each portion. Then, by using Eq.
5.12 and 5.13 the maximum shear stress of the distribution of shear stress on the
shaft cross-section can be determined.
For example, in the case shown in Fig. 5.11, the torque at the cut plane is
T TB TE (4.18)
Let the radius of the cross-section at the cut lane be R, the
maximum stress on this section would be
(TB TE ) R 2(TB TE )
t max (4.19)
1
R 4 R 3
Fig . 11
2
Stresses in the elastic range (Example)
Example 1
The largest twist load is directly related to the largest shear stress
J .t max
Tmax
c
Stresses in the elastic range (Example)
Calculation of the polar moment of area
1
J (co4 ci4 )
2
1
J (0.034 0.024 ) 1.02110 6 m4
2
J .t max 1.021106 (120 106 )
Tmax 4.08 kN m
c 0.03
Solution of part (b)
Both shafts carry equal torques and both have the same allowable
shear stress and diameter. So, we consider only portion AB.
Stresses in the elastic range (Example)
cd /2
TAB .c 2TAB 16TAB
(t max ) AB
1 4 c3 d 3
c
2
1/3 1/3
16TAB 16 (6 106 ) d 78 mm
d 77.76 mm
(t all ) AB 65( )
Example 3
The solid spindle AB is made of steel with an allowable shearing
stress of 12 ksi and the sleeve CD is made of brass with an
allowable shearing stress of 7 ksi. Determine
(a) the largest torque T that can be applied at A if the allowable
shearing stress is not to be exceeded in sleeve CD.
(b) The corresponding required value of diameter ds of spindle AB.
(c) If the solid spindle AB has a diameter of ds=1.5 in, determine
the largest torque T that can be applied at A.
Stresses in the elastic range (Example)
Solution part (a)
Polar moment of area for the sleeve CD
do 3
c0 1.5 in
2 2
d d 2t 3 0.5
ci i o 1.25 in
2 2 2
1 1
J CD (co4 ci4 ) (1.54 1.254 ) 4.117 in 4
2 2
The torque applied to the sleeve CD is equal to the torque T.
T .co J CD (t all )CD 4.117(7 103 )
(t max )CD Tmax 19.21 103 lb in
J CD co 1.5
Solution part (b)
Maximum shear stress in spindle for applied torque of 19.21×10³
1 1 d 1
J AB cs4 ( s ) 4 d s4
2 2 2 32
T .d s 16T
(t max ) AB
2 J CD d s3
Stresses in the elastic range (Example)
1/3 1/3
16T 16 19.21103
ds 2.013 in d s 2 in
(t all ) AB (12 10 )
3
T .cs T .cs 2T
t max 3
Js 1 4 cs
cs
2
2T
(t all ) s
(cs )3min
2T 2(10 10 3
)
(cs ) min 3 3 0.7515 in.
(t all ) s 15 10 3
2T 2(10 10 3
)
(cb ) min 3 3 0.9266 in.
(t all )b 8 10 3
db 1.85 in.
Angle of twist in elastic torsion
4.3. Angle of twist in elastic torsion
4.3.1 Angle of twist in elastic portion for uniform cross section
To develop a relationship between the twist angle f and the applied torque, T, first, we
consider a uniform circular shaft with radius c and length L under the action of the torque
T. Assuming elastic behavior, the maximum shear strain is
cf
max (4.18)
L
In the elastic range, shear strain is related
to the shear strain as
t max
max (4.19)
G
Recalling Eq. 4.12, for tmax
1 T .c T .c
max ( ) (4.20) Fig . 12
G J GJ
Angle of twist in elastic torsion
Replacing max from Eq. 5.18, we can relate the angle of twist to the applied torque T.
T .L
f (4.21)
GJ
Where f is in radians. Eq. 4.21 shows that the elastic angle of twist is proportional to T.
It is noted that in derivation of Eq. 5.21, one end of the shaft is considered to be fixed. If it is not the case,
Eq. 5.21 will represent the relative angle of twist between two ends of the shaft.
By using Eq. 4.21 an experiment can be set up to determine the shear modulus of elasticity G. If
we apply various magnitudes of torque to a particular shaft with definite length L and measure
the resulting angle of twist, then by plotting T against f, a line should obtained. Slope of this line
represents L/GJ, from which G can be determined.
Example 5
The hollow shaft of Example 1 is showed here again. If G for the
material is 77 GPa, determine (a) The required torque to a twist of
2° (b) The value of the angle of twist which crates a shearing
stress of 70 GPa on the inner surface of the hollow shaft.
Angle of twist in elastic torsion (Example)
Part (a)
Converting f to radians,
2
f 2 34.9 10 3
rad
360
Recalling from Example 1
J 1.021106 m 4
T .L
f
GJ
GJ (1.02110 6 )(77 10 9 )
T f (34.9 10 3 ) 1.829 103 N .m T 1.829 kN .m
L 1.5
Part (b)
Shear strain at the inner surface of the shaft
t min
min
G
Angle of twist in elastic torsion (Example)
70
min 0.909 10 3
mm / mm
77 10 3
Because L and the material is the same for two shafts, the angles
of twist is the same proportion as the shear stress
T .L
f
GJ
Angle of twist in elastic torsion (Example)
fhollow J solid
1.15
fsolid J hollow
Weights of the shafts are proportional to their cross sectional areas
Asolid r 2
Ahollow (ro2 ri 2 ) (r 2 (0.6r ) 2 ) 0.64r 2
(W ) hollow Ahollow 0.64 r 2
0.64
(W ) solid Asolid r2
The results show that hollow shaft has 15% more stress and angle of twist than
the solid shaft but with 36% lower weight.
4.3.2 Angle of twist in elastic portion for non-uniform cross section
In stepped shafts with multiple sections, it is necessary to calculate the angle of twist for each
portion and add them together to find the total angle of twist. The same rule applies to shafts
with multiple material properties and the shafts with multiple torques at different locations.
Angle of twist in elastic torsion
For example consider Fig. 13, a stepped shaft
with four loading torques. The material is the
same for two parts and radii of the parts are r1
and r2. The angle of twist at the point B is
Ti .Li
3
fB (4.22)
i 1 GJ
i
Torque in each part is Fig . 13
T T1 part with length L1
T T1 T2 part with length L2
T T1 T2 T3 part with length L3
1 2T1 L1 2(T1 T2 ) L2 2(T1 T2 T3 ) L3
fB ( 4 )
G r1 r24
r24
Angle of twist in elastic torsion
■ For a shaft with variable circular cross section as shown in Fig. 14, J is a function of x. The
angle of twist for a sliced element (dx) can be written as
Tdx
df (4.23)
G.J ( x)
Now, by integration, the angle of twist at B (relative to
the end point A) can be written as
L Tdx T L dx
fB f A (4.24)
0 G.J ( x ) G 0 J ( x)
If one of the shaft’s faces is fixed to a support, Eq. 4.24
will give the absolute angel of twist at the other end.
Fig . 14
Angle of twist in elastic torsion (Example)
Example 6
The horizontal shaft AD is attached to fixed base at D and is subjected to the torques shown. A 44-
mm-diameter hole is drilled into portion CD of the shaft. Knowing that the entire shaft is made of
steel for which G=77 GPa, determine the angle of twist at the end A
Portion BC:
Angle of twist in elastic torsion (Example)
Portion BC:
1 2 1
J BC rBC (30) 4 1272348 mm 4
2 2
LBC 200 mm
Portion DC:
1 1
J CD (ro4 ri 4 ) (304 224 ) 904379 mm 4
2 2
LCD 600 mm
T L dx T L dx 2T L dx
f
G 0 J ( x) G 0 1 c 4 (2 x ) 4 c 4G 0 (2 x ) 4
2 L L
L
2T L 2TL 1 1 7TL
f 4 4 [ ]
c G 3(2 x )3 c G 3 24 12 c 4G
L 0
Statically indeterminate twisting shafts
4.4. Statically indeterminate twisting shafts
There are situations that the internal force and/or reaction forces cannot be determined from
statics (For example see Fig. 15). In such cases, additional equations should be derived by using
geometry and deformation analysis of the structure.
Fig . 15
Statically indeterminate twisting shafts (Example)
Example 8
A circular shaft AB consists of a 10 in long, 7/8 in diameter. Steel
cylinder, in which a 5 in long, 7/8 in diameter cavity has been drilled
from end B. The shaft is attached to fixed supports at both ends, and
a 90 lb-ft torque is applied at its midsection. Determine the torque
exerted on the shaft by each of the supports.
Polar moments of inertia
1 1 7
J AC r 4 ( ) 4 0.05755 in 4
2 2 16
1 1 7 5
J CB (ro4 ri 4 ) [( ) 4 ( ) 4 ] 0.04257 in 4
2 2 16 16
Considering two unknown torques at A and B, torques
equilibrium equation can be written as
TA TB T
Angle of twist for part AC
Statically indeterminate twisting shafts (Example)
Angle of twist for part AC Angle of twist for part CB
TL T L T2 LCB TB LCB
fCA 1 AC A AC fCB
GJ AC GJ AC GJ CB GJ CB
Compatibility of twist angle at C
f AB 0
fB f A 0
fB f A fC fC 0
(fB fC ) (fC f A ) 0 fCB fCA 0
TA LAC (TB ) LCB
0
GJ AC GJ CB
LAC J CB 5 0.04257 TA
620.77
51.73 lb ft
TB TA TA . 0.74TA
LCB J AB 5 0.05755 12
TB T TA 90 51.73 38.27 lb ft
Statically indeterminate twisting shafts (Example)
Example 9 T1=1 kN-m T2=1.5 kN-m
A stepped solid circular shaft with two end-fixed
D
supports has been shown in the figure. The shaft A B C
is made of steel with G=77 GPa. Determine the
maximum shear stress in the shaft.
L1=400 m
L3=600 mm
Solution by the method of superposition d1=40 mm
d3=25 mm
L2=500 mm
Calculation of polar moment of area. d2=60 mm
J DC 4
d DC (25) 4 3.8 104 mm 4
32 32 T1=1 kN-m T2=1.5 kNm
J CB 4
dCB (60) 4 127 104 mm 4
32 32 D
A B C
J BA 4
d BA (40) 4 25.1104 mm 4
32 32
Statically indeterminate twisting shafts (Example)
First release support D and calculate the angle of twist at D. T1=1 kN-m T2=1.5 kNm
TDC 0.
D
TCB 1.5 106 N .mm A B C
TBA 2.5 10 6
N .mm
TDC LDC TCB LCB TBA LBA
fD(1)
GJ DC GJ CB GJ BA
1.5 106 (500) 2.5 106 (400)
f (1)
D 0
77 10 127 10 77 103 25.110 4
3 4
TD
f (1)
D
3 3
7.7 10 51.7 10 59.4 10 3
rad
D
Now apply a twisting moment TD at the support D A B C
and calculate the angle of twist at the point D.
TDC TCB TBA TD
Statically indeterminate twisting shafts (Example)
TDC LDC TCB LCB TBA LBA
fD(2) T1=1 kN-m T2=1.5 kN-m
GJ DC GJ CB GJ BA
T LDC LCB LBA D
f (2)
D D A C
G J J J B
DC CB BA
fA RB
n (4.26)
fB RA
Note that the negative sign is used to emphasis for
the different directions of fA and fB.
Fig . 16
Gears in torsion assemblies
■ The ratio RB/RA is known as the gear assembly ratio. Due to the definition of the angular
velocity (w = d(f)/dt), therefore, the ratio of angular velocities is also expressed by the same
gear ratio.
wA RB
n (4.27)
wB RA
Since two mating gears mush have the same pitch distance value (angular distance
between two similar points in two adjacent tooth measured on the pitch circle), Thus
NB
n (4.28)
NA
■ Thus, the fundamental kinematic and geometry equation of two mating gears can be written
as:
Gears in torsion assemblies
wA N R
B B n (4.29)
wB N A RA
F .Rc T2
T2 315 103
F
Rc Rc
The tangential force F transmitted to teeth of the gear B.
T
F 1
RB
T1 315 103 R
T1 315 103 B
RB Rc Rc
Since RB/RA is regraded as the gear ratio, n, T1 can be determined
RB N B 54
n 1.2857 T1 315 103 (1.2857) 405 N .m
Rc N c 42
Gears in torsion assemblies (example)
Maximum shear stresses in two shafts
T1 D1 (405 103 )(35)
t1 48.2 MPa
2 J1 2(14.7 104 )
T2 D2 (315 103 )(30)
t2 59.4 MPa
2J2 2(7.95 104 )
■ The Power transmitted by shafts is related to the torque and the speed of rotation.
P T .w (4.33)
Where T is the torque in N.m, w is the rotational speed (angular
velocity) in rad/sec and P is the transmitted power in N.m/sec or
Watts.
■ Sometimes the rotational speed is given in RPM (revolutions per minute). In such cases,
for changing RPM to rad/sec, it must be multiplied by 2/60.
2
1 rpm rad / sec
60
Power transmission by shafts
■ When US customary units are used, the rotational speed is usually expressed in RPM and
the power in horsepower (hp). The torque can then be expressed in lb-in or lb-ft.
1 hp 550 lb. ft / sec
1 hp 6600 [Link] / sec
Example 12
■ What size of shaft should be used for the rotor of a 5-hp motor operating at 3600 RPM if
the shearing stress is not to exceed 8500 psi in the shaft?
Power transmission by shafts (example)
Using Eq. 4.26, the transmitted torque is calculated
Tw 63000 P 63000 5
P T 87.5 lb in
63000 w 3600
(d o ) min 133 mm
(di ) min 80 mm