Understanding Cooper Pairs in Superconductors
Understanding Cooper Pairs in Superconductors
Chapter 8
SUPERCONDUCTIVITY
�TRODUCTION:
The zero electrical resistivity of superconductors implies zero losses and hence
lectrical power can be transported over very large distances with undiminished strength
y superconducting cables. Complete diamagnetism of superconductor causes strong
�pulsion of magnets from the vicinity of a superconductor. This effect can be utilized
1 different areas of technology.
�ERCONDUCTIVITY:
167
Eng ,leering Physics
has
critical temperature below passes
Tc Temperature (K) over mto the sta-te. The
for
Fig. 8.1
chemically pure and structurally perfect
while the transition range' is broad (of the order of one tenth of a degree or
so) in case of specimens containing impurities or specimens which are structurally
imperfect.
� HE DISCOVERY:
'
Temperature K
�-
4.15K. Fig. shows the result of classical experi-
8.2
ment conducted by Onnes in The sudden drop
1911.
Fig. 82
in resistivity was not in accordance with the expectations and was recognized by
Onnes to be an entirely a new phenomenon. He called this property as superconduc
tivity. Subsequently, was also discovered in lead, tin, zinc. alum'-
168
Superconductivity
num and other metals as well as number of alloys. Kammerlingh Onnes was hon
ored in 1913 with the Nobel prize in Physics for his
� RO ELECTRICAL RESISTANCE:
Hcri
was devised by Kammerhngh
Onnes. It consists of --
measur-
.
a closed
superconducting
ring is kept in a magnetic field
(Fig. 8.4) and it is cooled to
below the critical temperature
so that it becomes supercon (a)
Fig. 8.4 (b)
ducting. When the external
magnetic fleld is switched off, a current is induced in the ring. If the ring had a finite
resistance R, the current circulating in the ring would decrease according to the equa-
tion.
169
Engineering Physics
� SISTENT CURRENT:
� FFECT OF TEMPERATURE:
A subsequent study of the resistivity of metals reveled that mercury was not the
only element which exhibited superconductivity. A number of elements and alloys
exhibit superconductivity. There are listed in Table 8.1.
170
Superconductivity
1 Cd 0.55
2 AI 1.19
3 Hg 4.15
4 Nb 9.2
6 NbN 16
7 V3Si 17.1
8 Nb3Sn 18
9 Nb3Ge 23.2
10 YBa2Cu307 90
11 Tl2Ga2Ba2Cu3010 125
As seen from the 8.1, the critical temperature of most of the metals and
alloys is quite low. In fact the maximum critical temperature recorded was for Nb3Ge
which was about 23.2 K. However, in 1987, the compound of yitrium branium copper
oxide (e.g. YBa2C u307) and somewhere in 1990 the compound ofThallium (Tl) and
Gallium (Ga) was about 125 K. This discovery has opened up a new subject matter
called the "high temperature superconductivity".
m
p= --
2
ne r
where m - mass of electron
T- the average time of collision which electrons undergo with the lattice ions.
171
Engineering Physics
becomes infinite at sufficiently low temperature, then the resistivity vanishes entirely,
as observed in superconductivity.
172
Superconductivity
� SNER EFFECT:
In view of zero resistivity of the specimen, we may initially conclude that the
state is not
a novel state only a state
where the specimen be
haves as an ideal
Hex! Hext � 0 tor. Let us examine how
such a is right.
It an ordinary conductor, a
steady current requires an
(a) Fig. 8.6 (b) electric field to overcome
the resistance. The electric
field within a conductor carrying a given current density is directly proportional to the
resistivity.
It follows from Eqn. ( 1) that E 0 for a perfect conductor. It means that the
electrical field cannot exists inside the perfect conductor. a perfect conductor
is in a magnetic field and the magnetic field is switched off, the changing
flux will not induce an emf in it. According to one of the Maxwell's equations
aB
Vx£ =-a; .. . Faraday's law
.
173
Engineering Physics
! cooling
This property is indepen
dent of the path by which
the superconducting state
is reached (Fig.8.7). Sup
pose the magnetic field is
applied first to the sample
H"",-+0
in the normal state as in
Fig. 8.7 Let the material
be cooled belowT,
c in the
(a) (b) (c)
presence of the magnetic
Fig. 8.7 field. It is expected that
the magnetic flux through
the material would remain unchanged as in Fig.8.6 However Meissner and Ochsenfeld
found that magnetic flux was totally expelled from the sample as it become supercon
ducting (Fig. 8.7(b)) The expulsion of magnetic flux during the transition from the
normal to the superconducting state is called the Meissner effect. The experiments of
Meissner established that as the temperature is lowered, the specimen enters super
conducting state at T = Tc and magnetic flux is pushed out of it for all temperatures
T < Tc. The effect is reversible. When the temperature is raised from below Tc, the
flux suddenly starts penetrating the specimen at T Tc, as a result of which material
returns back to the normal state.
B = ).10 ( H + M)
At T < T,
c B = 0 and )l 0
(H + M)= 0 ... ..... . . . .....superconducting state
.
M=-H
M
X = -1 . . ... ..... Perfect Diamagnetism
H
= .
174
Superconductivity
more. Superconductor has an additional property that a resistance less conductor would
not have. A material in the state does not permit any magnetic flux to
exist within the body of the material. Meissner effect shows that in the supercondu c -
dB
tor not only 0 , but also B 0. The superconducting state is a characteristic
dT =
thermodynamic phase of a substance in which the material cannot sustain steady elec
tric and magnetic fields.
On the basis of magnetic behavior, superconductors are classified into two cat
egories, namely Type I and Type II Superconductors or soft and hard superconductors
respectively.
J
perconductors are perfectly
diamagnetic below He and
completely expel the magnetic
H H He
175
Engineering Physics
The magnetic f clci .)an penetrate only the surface layer and current can only flow
this layer. Consequently Type I superconductors are poor carriers of electrical current.
Fig. 8.9
Comlete
Mixed State -- Normal field has completely
Diamagnestim
etrated and destroyed
superconductivity. In the region between Hc1 and HC2, the material is in a
cally mixed state but electrically it is superconductor. Hc2 can be as high as 20 to
2
Wb/m and the retention of superconductivity in such high magnetic fields
Type II materials very useful and application of creating very high magnetic
Transition metals and alloys consisting of niobium, aluminum, silicon and
exhibit Type II superconductivity.
176
Superconductivity
created by superconductor solenoid, it does not require electric power to maintain it.
However, the solenoid must be held below the critical temperature Tc, which is ac
complished by liquid helium.
The fundamental idea underlying BCS theory is that electrons pair up with one
another due to a special type of attractive interaction. These pairs of electrons, called
cooper pairs, are of opposite momenta and spin. They can be scattered only if the
energy involved is sufficient to break it up into two single electrons. In general this
energy will not be available and so electron pair moves on undeviated by either impu
rities or thermal vibrations.
Normally two electrons repel each other, however, Frohlich, realized in 1952
that electrons could attracts each other via distortion of the lattice. The idea is as
follows:
177
Engineering Physics
The BCS theory was also able to account for the energy gap. Since an electron
pair has lower energy than the two normal electrons there is an energy gap between
the paired and the two single electrons.
The BCS theory is also able to explain many other phenomenon associated with
superconductivity such as Meissner effect, flux penetration etc.
The energy gap is generally of the order of 1 Q-3 eV. The existence of an energy
178
Superconductivity
gap can be proved experimentally. One such experiment studying the ab
sorption of microwaves by a superconductors. At temperature close to absolute zero,
a superconductor does not absorb energy until the energy quanta of incident radiation
is equal to or greater than 2L1. The absorption grows fast to a value typical for the
normal metal, because electrons can now absorb photons and go to higher energy
states that lie above the gap.
h
0= n -
2e
or 0=n00 • • • • • • • • • • • • • n=l,2,3, ......
h
where 0o= is the flux quantum and called fluxon.
2e
Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer were awarded the Nobel prize in Physics in
1972. Bardeen received the Nobel prize for second time, the first being in 1956 along
with Shockley and Brattain for the intention of transistor.
179
Engineering Physics
8.11.1 DC EFFECT:
Two superconductors separated by a thick insulating layer, say 10 nm, are es
sentially two independent superconductors without any joint properties. When they
are separated by a thin insulating layer (1 nm thick) they become a system of coupled
conductors. The Cooper pair tunnels through the barrier (insulating layer) as a single
unit. Such an arrangement is often referred as weak link.
Superconductor
Insulating barier
Insulator
(a) (b)
Fig. 8.11
where 8 is the phase difference between the wave function describing Cooper
pairs on both sides of the barrier, and
Ic is the critical current which the junction can support. Ic is depPnt! �nt on the
thickness and width of the insulating layer. It is usm11ly very small
1 �,')
Superconductivity
8.11.2 AC EFFECT:
u= -
2eV
h
.................... (2)
I=
s
Ic sin ( 4;rev
h
t ) .................(4)
By virtue of the ac Josephson effect, the volt has replaced the ampere as the
fundamental unit of electromagnetism. One volt is now defined as the potential dif
ference which, when impressed across a Josephson junction, will generate electro
Leo Esaki, Ivan Giaever and BrianD Josephon was awarded with Nobel prize
in physics 1973 for their work on electron tunneling.
181
Engineering Physics
�PPLICATIUNS:
1. Electricity is transmitted and distributed through cables. A large amount of power,
about one-fifth the quantity generated, is lost on way due to FR losses. When
superconductors will be used as cables, these losses are avoided and electrical
power transmission can be done at a lower voltage level.
3. There has been proposal for making superconducting power transmission lines.
In principle extremely large amount of de power can be transmitted over large
distances without much loss. Model superconducting cables have been built
and large current have been carried over short distances.
7. The Meissner effect can be embodied in bearing that would operate without
friction losses in all kinds of rotating machines.
182
Superconductivity
9. The method of magnetic separation for refining ores and chemicals has been
carried out employing superconducting magnets.
10. Phase transition from the superconducting to normal state can be effected by
means of an external magnetic field. This principle can be used in
devices.
1 1. High magnetic fields are required in many areas of research and diagnostic equip
ments in medicine. The electromagnets are cumbersome being very big in size,
demand large electrical power to maintain the magnetic field and require con
tinuous cooling
12. Several medical diagnostic equipments are now employing SQUIDs which de
tect very minute changes in the magnetic field of a human brain or body..
13. magnets are used for NMR imaging which has promising ap
plications in the field of medicine in the form of NMR tomography. NMR to
mography is of particular importance for the investigation of pathological
in the brain.
14. Superconducting magnets are extensively used in high energy physics experi
ments. with large particle accelerators are many magnets of high
fields and high homogeneity used for bending and guiding the accelerated
particles.
15. Superconducting solenoids produce very strong magnetic fields. They are small
in size and does not need power. Thus, they are less cumbersome and less
expensive.
1 83
Engineering Physics
17. They are also used for measuring magnetic fields with high accuracy. The ac
Josephson effect is employed for the accurate measurement of voltages.
18. Bubble chamber magnets are another example of the applications of supercon
ducting magnets in high energy physics.
19. Controlled nuclear fusion requires confining high temperature plasma in a closed
region and that is done by employing magnetic field. Superconducting magnets
are used for this purpose.
20. The semiconductor logic elements have a speed limit. They operate at speeds of
nanoseconds. In contrast, logic elements based on Josephson junction can oper
ate at a few picoseconds. Josephson junction are therefore expected to increase
the speed of supercomputers.
*****
Question Bank
184
Superconductivity
APPINDEX-1
SOME PHYSICAL CONSTANTS
Constant Notation Unit
Speed of light c 3.00 X 108 mls
Gravitational constant G 6.67 X I0-11 N · m2 I kg 2
Avogadro constant NA 6.02 X I 023 mol·1
Universal gas constant R J I moi·K
Mass-energy relation cz 8.99 X Jlkg.,
931.5 MeVIu
Permittivity constant €o 8.85 X 10 12 Flm
constant 1.26 X 10 6 Him
Planck constant h 6.63 x 10 34 1-s,
4.14 X 10-15 eV·s
Boltzmann constant k 1.38 x ro-2l J/K
8.62 X 1 0 s eVIk
Electron charge e 1.60 X 10-1Y c
rest mass m
e
9.11 X 1031 kg.
Proton rest mass m 1.67 X J0·27 kg
p
Bohr radius ao
5.29 X I0-11 m
Bohr magneton l B
9.27 X I0-24 J/T
5.79X
185
Engineering Physics
APPINDEX - III
SI PREFIXES
Multiplication Factor Prefix symbol
1 Q18 exa E
1 Q 15 peta p
I012 tetra T
I09 giga G
I 06 mega M
I03 kilo k
2
IQ hecto h
1 01 deka da
IQ 1 deci d
2
IQ- centi c
IQ 3 milli m
I0 6 micro
9
J0 nano n
2
IQ-1 pico p
IQ 1 5
femto f
8
I o-1 atto a
APPINDEX - IV
PREFIXES IN MARATHI
O
JO �
I I
O �
2
I0 �
I0 3 �
10 4 �
5
J0 "Rat
6
1Q rmM&l
0
I 7 <itiT
8
10 �
I09 3lWf
O
IQI �
i l
IO �
2
IOI �
1
I0 3 �
4
101 �
s
I o1 �
O I6
J "qt<J
7
IOl -qutf
186
Superconductivity
APPINDEX- V
NOBEL LAUREATES IN PHYSICS
1902
Hendrik Antoon Lorentz 1853-1928 their researches in to the influence of magnetism up
Pieter Zeeman 1865-1943 on radiation
Antoine Henri Bc cq uerel 1852-1908 his discovery of
1903
radioactivity;
Pierre Curie their joint researches on rad iation phenomenon
Marie Sklodowskan Curie 1867-193 discovered Prof. Henri
1904
John William Strutt investigations of the densities of the most important
1842-1919
(Lord and his of
1905
Eduard
his work on cathode rays
Anton von Lenard
1906
his and investigations on
John Thomson 1856-1940
of bv
1907
his optical precision and metrological
Albert Abraham Michelson 1852-1931
carried out with their aid
1908
his of reproducing colours photographi cally
Gabriel Lippama nn 1845-1921
based on of
1909
Guglielmo Marconi 1874-1937 their contribution to the development of wireless
Karl Ferdinand Braum 1850-1918
1910
Johannes Diderik
1837-1932 his work on the equation of state of gases and liquids.
van der Waals
1911
his discoveries regarding the laws governing the
Wilhelm Wi en 1864-1928
radiation of heat.
his invention of automatic regulators for use in
1912 Nils Gustaf Da len conjunction with gas accumulators for illu minating
and
his in ves tigations of the properties of matter at low
11913 Heike Kamerlingh Onnes 1853-1926 temperature which led, inter alia to the production of
helium.
1914
Theodor Felix his discovery of the diffraction of Rontgen rays by
1879-1960
von Laue
1915
William Henry Bragg 1862-1942 their services in the analysis of crystal structure by
William Lawrence I 890-197 I means of
1917
his discovery of the characteristics X-rays of the
Charles Glover Barkla 1877-1944
elements.
1918 Max Planck 1858-1947 his of
1919
his of the Doppler effect in canal rays and
Johannes Stark 1874-1957
the of lines in electric tields.
the service he has rendered to precision measurements
1920 Charles Edouard Guillaume 1861-1938 in Physics by his discovery of anomalies in nickel
stee I alloys.
1921
his to Theoretical Physics and especially for
Albert Einstein 1879-1955
his of the laws of effect.
1922
the investigation of the structure of atoms and of the
Niels Henrik David Bohr 1885-1962
radiation from
187