Big Data Project Management Insights
Big Data Project Management Insights
Introduction to Project
Management
Figure 1.2 Good project management, careful planning, and an early focus on business outcomes help
Citibank increase its chances of success in big data projects.
promotional spending or analyze transactional use case and find other ways of solving the business
records for anomalies, to systems that use big data problem. Clearly, good project management, careful
to predict errors or fraudulent behaviors. planning, and an early focus on business outcomes
At the same time, Citibank’s organizational unit help Citibank increase its chances of success in its
responsible for big data projects has realized that big data projects.
big data may not be the silver bullet for a particular
Based on: Marr (2016).
Introduction
Every day, you encounter countless examples of projects organizations undertake, rang-
ing from Amazon upgrading its data center infrastructure to Citibank implementing
big data projects to companies revising their privacy policies to comply with new regu-
lations, such as the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation. All these projects require
a decision regarding their priority versus other potential projects; they all require a plan,
the execution of that plan, and on completion, an assessment of how well the team or
person doing the project followed the plan—and they all eventually come to an end.
Projects can be simple endeavors requiring the attention of only one individual, or
they can be extensive undertakings combining the resources of thousands of people.
They can last anywhere from several days to many years. Most of us do not follow a
specific methodology to do all the things that might be classified as projects in our
everyday lives; yet as projects grow in importance, complexity, and length, it becomes
increasingly important for organizations to have systematic processes for managing them
Figure 1.3 As projects grow in importance, complexity, and length, systematic project management processes
become increasingly important.
(see Figure 1.3). This book is about how organizations and the people within them can
effectively manage information systems (IS) projects.
In this chapter, you will learn what projects are and, conversely, what they are not.
You will also learn about the specific nature of information systems projects, how all
types of projects share many common elements but also how they all present unique
challenges. We will then describe project management and its history, and introduce
agile methodologies. You will also learn how technology can be used to help manage
projects and how technology can be classified. You will then learn why the study of proj-
ect management is important by examining some statistics regarding project failures,
some specific examples of project failures, and finally, some possible causes of project
failures. You will also gain a basic understanding of what can be done to help ensure
project success.
What Is a Project?
Depending upon the source, the definition of the term project may vary. As an example,
Project Management
Institute the New Oxford American Dictionary defines a project as “an individual or collabo-
An association rative enterprise that is carefully planned and designed to achieve a particular aim.”
designed to bring
together project Each project has a goal or specific purpose, a duration, and resource requirements such
management profes- as money, people, infrastructure, and technology. The Project Management Institute
sionals to enhance
organizational success (PMI), an association designed to bring together project management professionals
by maturing the to enhance organizational success by maturing the project management profession,
project management
profession. describes projects as temporary endeavors designed to achieve a unique result, product,
Project
or service. For the purpose of this book, we have chosen a definition that incorporates
A planned undertaking dimensions of all of these descriptions, defining a project as “a planned undertaking of
of related activities
to achieve a unique
related activities to achieve a unique outcome that has a specified duration.” In organi-
outcome that has a zations, individual projects are grouped as programs, which help harness synergies. For
specified duration.
example, a company might develop a mobile app for its salespeople as part of a mobile
Program enterprise program. A portfolio may include a variety of projects or programs—which
Related projects
coordinated to harness may or may not be directly related (e.g., in the case of setting up a new business unit or
synergies. launching new product lines)—to reach strategic objectives (see Figure 1.4).
Portfolio Projects, programs, and portfolios are executed to meet a specific need for a stake-
A group of projects or holder or group of stakeholders. Stakeholders are those entities that are actively
programs (which may
not be directly related) involved in the project, who have a vested interest in its success, or who have a positive
pursued to reach or negative influence over the project and its results.
strategic objectives.
Projects are also temporary in that they begin and end on specific predetermined
Stakeholder dates. Project teams are often formed at the beginning of a project and then disbanded
An individual, group,
or organization that is at its completion, with team members being reassigned to new projects. As a result,
actively involved in the project team dynamics are often different from the dynamics of other, more permanent
project or has a vested
interest in its success teams such as those used in a production environment. Finally, projects need support
and/or has a positive from senior-level executives. A project sponsor is a member of the organization who
or negative influence
over the project and its
is responsible for the high-level support of the project. The project sponsor has the
results responsibility of making sure the project is given the resources necessary for its suc-
Project sponsor
cessful completion. Resources can include personnel and facilities, as well as any other
A member of the needs the project personnel may have.
organization who is Business projects frequently have an assigned project manager. In information sys-
responsible for the
high-level support of tems projects, the project manager needs a diverse set of skills—general management,
the project. leadership, technical, conflict management, and customer relationship management.
Project manager The project manager is responsible for managing a project as it goes through its indi-
A person with a diverse vidual phases from concept to completion; given that project management is largely
set of skills—general
management, leader- a team sport, a project manager’s role often focuses more on facilitating, rather than
ship, technical, conflict on monitoring and controlling. A project manager’s environment is one of continual
management, and
customer relationship change and problem solving. Typically, the project manager is a very experienced sys-
management—who is tems analyst; in other organizations, junior and senior analysts work together to manage
responsible for manag-
ing a project as it goes
parts of a project, with the more junior member supporting and learning from a more
through its individual senior colleague. Understanding the project management process is a critical skill for
phases from concept your future success. A project manager is often referred to as a juggler keeping many
to completion.
balls in the air that reflect the various aspects of a project’s development. Balancing
Project success the three key aspects time, costs, and scope, the project manager is instrumental to the
The degree to which
project objectives have successful completion of any project (see Figure 1.5). In fact, project success is often
been achieved on time, defined as the degree to which project objectives have been achieved on time, within
within budget, and
with the agreed upon budget, and with the agreed upon quality and scope.
quality and scope. Information systems projects are undertaken for two primary reasons: to take
advantage of business opportunities and to solve business problems (Figure 1.6). Taking
advantage of an opportunity might mean providing an innovative service to customers
through the creation of a new system. For example, a sports apparel brand may want
to create a new tennis shoe that pairs with a mobile app to allow customers to analyze
their running performance. Solving a business problem could involve modifying how an
existing system processes data to provide users more accurate or timely information. For
example, in order to reduce the number of telephone calls received by their sales staff,
this same brand may want to provide ways for the potential customers to see exactly
which products suit their individual needs and fitness levels.
Figure 1.5 Balancing the three key aspects time, costs, and scope, the project manager is instrumental to the
successful completion of any project.
Figure 1.6 Information systems projects are undertaken to take advantage of business opportunities and to
solve business problems.
Once a potential project has been identified, a feasibility study may need to be
conducted. This involves determining the resources and time required for the project’s
completion. To determine which resources are necessary, the scope of the project is
analyzed and the probability of successful completion is determined. The organization
can then use this information to decide whether the project is feasible, given time and
resource constraints. If so, the team conducts a more in-depth analysis. As you will
see, a primary skill of a project manager is to determine a project’s scope, time, and
resource requirements. These and other skills and related techniques will be covered in
subsequent chapters.
Association of Software and Services Companies More than two decades ago, companies were
(NASSCOM) predicting that India’s IT industry will looking for inexpensive workers to support their own
grow by less than 10 percent but the demand for (domestic) workforce. Today’s increasingly complex
skilled IT workers will double by 2020. Given this IT environments make searching for the right mix
demand, as the labor costs in India continue to rise, of talents at the right costs ever more important. In
fact, a recent study by Stratistics Market Research
many companies have already started to look else-
Consulting has estimated that in 2015 companies
where when thinking about offshoring their work.
spent US$314.9 billion for global outsourcing of soft-
Whereas many U.S.-based IT service providers
ware and services, a number that was expected to
(ranging from Accenture to IBM Global Technology reach US$481.4 billion in 2022. Yet global outsourc-
Services) rely on overseas talent, overseas IT ser- ing projects are not without challenges; working with
vices providers (such as Infosys or Wipro) now have an external provider adds complexity and distance in
international offices in various countries to be closer time and space, and language barriers often hinder
to their clients. productivity.
Based on: NASSCOM (2014); Trent (2016); Valacich and Schneider (2018).
A sixth unique aspect of IS projects that creates a level of complexity beyond non-IS
projects is related to managing project scope. Project scope, which involves the planned
definition and size of a project, is likely to change in many projects; however, progres-
sive, uncontrolled increases in project scope (see the discussion of scope creep in Chap-
ter 5) and unclear requirements are commonplace in IS projects. In many instances, this
again might relate to the fact that the end product has never been developed before. In
such a situation, users may be less certain about what characteristics they want in the
final project output. In addition, users may naïvely believe that software projects are
easily modified even after they have begun—after all, it’s just changing a few lines of
code. It is up to the project team to manage these perceptions.
A seventh unique feature of IS projects is that the technologies involved in projects
may change during the course of the project, presenting a moving target for the project
team. As an example, a company may be involved in the deployment of an enterprise
system, such as SAP S4/HANA, for the purpose of connecting various functional
areas of the business, such as production, sales, and accounting. In the middle of such a
project, a new version of the system may be released, and the company may find itself
facing a decision of whether to continue with the original product or adopt the new
technology. Such changes in technology are commonplace, adding to the complexity of
managing projects of this nature. In some cases, the technology might become obsolete
before the project is even finished.
In contrast to other projects, such as building a bridge, IS projects are associated
with a host of other challenges. For example, while the complexity of constructing
bridges has remained relatively stable over time, the required functionality of software
is constantly increasing, leading to exponential increases in code base and complexity.
Likewise, it is estimated that in large IS development projects, an average of a thousand
decisions have to be made for each US$1 million in labor costs. Consequently, it is now
nearly impossible to test each logical path within the software’s source code—even
using automated tools—and almost no software can ever be free of errors or defects.
While many latent defects may only surface under very specific circumstances, they
can pose critical vulnerabilities. The likelihood and impact of attacks is increasing, as a
malicious cracker only needs to discover a single hole and the tools for this are becom-
ing increasingly sophisticated.
Further, software, in and of itself, is unique in a sense that it is invisible (i.e., the
user only interacts with the system image) and there are no physical laws that guide or
determine the results of a certain operation or change to the code. Complicating matters
further, there are few “laws” in software development, and the field is constantly evolv-
ing, with new methods and new approaches (such as agile); for many new methodolo-
gies, developers follow a trial and error approach, as just too little is known about why
things work or don’t work, or about the circumstances under which they can be used.
Another issue is associated with project planning and execution: while, for example, the
size and complexity of construction projects can be estimated using well-established
tools and techniques, few such tools exist for IS project; likewise, especially for large
and complex systems, only limited tools are available to support development. Finally,
information systems do not operate in a vacuum, and many (if not most of ) today’s
systems are interlinked; consequently, the project manager and developers must extend
their focus beyond the system they are developing and also consider its interactions
with other systems.
Although projects may take many forms, one common factor most often leads to
project success—project management.
Discussion Questions
1. What was the most challenging ethical dilemma you have ever faced?
2. How did you resolve the dilemma?
Based on: American Management Association (2006); Valacich and Schneider (2018).
Figure 1.8 Project management process groups. Based on: PMBOK (2017).
their subprocesses, and project life cycles will be covered in greater detail in Chapter 2,
it will be useful to discuss the major process groups briefly here.
Before a project even begins, organizations must identify potential projects and
evaluate their importance to the organization. The need for IS projects can be discov-
ered in many ways, including recognition by managers and end users. Once these needs
have been identified, key management can evaluate the potential projects’ alignment
with company strategies and goals.
The processes in the initiating process group include authorizing the continuation
of an existing project or the start of a new project, developing the project charter, as
well as developing the project management plan. The processes in the planning process
group are conducted to plan crucial aspects of the project, such as scope, time, costs, and
Microsoft Project risks. Processes in this project group use project management tools (such as Microsoft
Software designed
by Microsoft to help Project) to create work breakdown structures (WBS; see Figure 1.9), Gantt charts,
people manage and network diagrams (see Figure 1.10), all of which will be discussed in later chapters.
projects.
The processes in the executing process group are concerned with completing the
Work breakdown actual project deliverables. The processes in the monitoring and controlling process
structure
A listing of the group are used to measure performance and progress and compare these against planned
activities necessary
for the completion of a
performance and progress. If problem areas are found, steps are taken to correct them.
project. Finally, the closing process group encompass processes such as finalizing all paperwork
Gantt chart and having all responsible parties sign off on the phase or project.
A bar chart showing The processes of the different process groups are further categorized as belonging
the start and end
dates for the activities to one of ten knowledge areas, such as scope management, cost management, or risk
of a project. management. These ten core knowledge areas, along with their associated processes, are
Network diagram listed in Table 1.1 (Note that throughout the book, process names corresponding to
A schematic display
that illustrates the
PMBOK are Capitalized and Italicized). When looking at these knowledge areas, their
various tasks in a ties to each of the project process groups of initiation, planning, execution, control, and
project, as well as their
sequential relationship.
closeout are evident. We will revisit this association throughout this book.
An important aspect to note is that while the PMBOK Guide describes good prac-
tices, it does not serve as a methodology per se, as it does not provide specific guidance
on which processes should be applied, how workflows should be organized, or who
should be responsible for what.
Figure 1.9 Sample work breakdown structure (WBS) in Microsoft Project 2016
• Professional development. Project managers can individuals who have sufficient project experience
attend educational events where they can learn and have passed a rigorous comprehensive exam-
about international and regional concerns of ination in project management.
other project managers through case studies and • Professional awards. Annual awards are presented
simulations. to PMI members who bring honor and recognition
• Networking. PMI members have the opportunity to the project management profession and PMI.
to interact with members from different organiza- • Career services. PMI also offers career services to
tions to develop relationships and work on advanc- project management professionals.
ing the project management profession.
• Publications. Along with its three periodicals, PMI
• Career advancement. PMI offers project manage- publishes project management books, training
ment professional (PMP) certification to those tools, and other learning products.
the Hoover Dam was not only successfully completed but completed ahead of time
and under budget.
The modern concept of project management originated in 1942 during the so-called
Manhattan Project (see Figure 1.14), which was the code name for the U.S. effort to
develop an atomic bomb during World War II. This project provided some of the
first evidence of the potential of modern project management techniques. It lasted
from 1942 to 1946, involved hundreds of scientists, and was accomplished at a cost of
Figure 1.14 Hanford Site in 1944. Source: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
approximately US$1.8 billion, which in today’s dollars would be well over US$20 bil-
lion. The necessary planning and security were so extensive that three secret cities were
built to support the Manhattan Project’s activities. Coordinating the huge number of
tasks necessary for this undertaking was a huge endeavor, and the project management
tools developed to do so are still in use today.
Critical path method Between 1958 and 1979, additional project management tools were introduced. These
A method used for tools included both the critical path method (CPM) and three-point-estimating.
determining the
sequence of task Figure 1.15 shows a network diagram for simple project, with different sequences of
activities that directly activities (labeled A–I). As you can see, different tasks may be completed in parallel, so
affect the completion
of a project. there may be multiple parallel paths in a project; the critical path is the longest path
Three-point estimating
through the diagram, indicating the shortest time in which a project can be completed.
A technique that Both the critical path method and three-point estimating are used in different ways
averages optimistic,
pessimistic, and
to estimate project durations and will be covered in depth in later chapters. Project
realistic time to management processes continued to evolve through the 1980s as the ability of project
calculate the expected
time for a particular
managers to exert local control over projects increased, due in part to the shift from
task. mainframe computing to personal computing technology.
and the outcomes were easily definable, the requirements of many systems today are
unclear and are likely to change quickly. As a result, traditional approaches—where
most of the work is determined upfront—are ill-suited, and companies are increasingly
Agile methodologies using agile methodologies for various projects. Agile approaches, placing the customer
Expedited approaches at the center, use an expedited approach to systems development focusing on iterative
to systems develop-
ment focusing on development, incremental delivery, and frequent feedback. In the early 2000s, a group
iterative development, of software developers published the Manifesto for Agile Software Development. The
incremental delivery,
and frequent feedback. agile manifesto emphasizes a focus on individuals and interactions, working software,
customer collaboration, and responding to change, as opposed to emphasizing processes
and tools, comprehensive documentation, contract negotiation, and following plans.
Following the agile manifesto, agile approaches use self-organizing teams and focus on
delivering working software frequently, so as to obtain rapid feedback from customers
and deliver valuable software. We will discuss the details of agile approaches in appen-
dices at the end of Parts I, II, and III, respectively.
of project management software can allow two or more project team members using
different computers to work together on various project activities. Such collaboration is
necessary for very large projects and when project members are not in the same location.
Because IS projects frequently include project members in dispersed locations (in many
instances team members may even be located in other countries), project management
software that supports collaboration gives project members up-to-date information on
the status of various project tasks.
Project management software can also be classified based on the software platform
on which it runs, such as Microsoft Windows, Linux, Apple’s Mac OS, or on mobile
platforms. In addition, a new trend is for companies to host project management soft-
ware in the cloud, in essence offering Software as a Service (SaaS). Web-based software
eliminates deployment problems, and a user requires only a web browser to use the soft-
ware. Such software, however, does not eliminate the need for skilled project managers;
rather, it is just a tool that aids project managers in accomplishing their objectives. The
large number of stand-alone and web-based project management packages available
illustrates the great demand for project management software and shows how import-
ant project management has become for the modern organization.
Project management software can also be industry specific. For example, Procore
focuses on construction projects. SYMPAQ SQL is geared toward project-oriented cost
accounting for government contractors. RoboHead focuses on projects in marketing
or creative sectors. Teamwork Project, from [Link], focuses on marketing, cre-
ative, software, and support teams. Software specific to a particular industry may have
built-in templates for activities that are common for that environment. These templates
may help reduce the time required for a user to input and generate a project plan and
the associated project activities. It may also guide the user to best practices used in that
specific industry.
An additional classification of project management software is based upon the
target market and price of the product. Products range from low-end software pack-
ages targeted at small companies to high-end, multiuser-licensed packages targeted at
enterprise organizations. An example of a relatively inexpensive web-based system is
Copper Project, which costs less than US$50 per month per user. In contrast, software
giant Oracle’s Primavera P6 Professional Project Management software package is
designed to run on stand-alone PC systems and costs US$2,500 per user. Probably the
Figure 1.17 Technical project management skills, strategic and business management skills, and leadership.
Based on: PMBOK (2017).
become familiar with a variety of processes, tools, and techniques for successfully man-
aging IS projects. Together, these skills will allow you to effectively communicate with
your team members, find solutions to obstacles encountered during a project, and suc-
cessfully complete a project.
Leadership
A key task of the project manager is facilitating and managing, rather than controlling.
A project manager not only leads the project team and communicates with the project
sponsor and other stakeholders, but also serves a critical role in communicating with
other members of the organization, the overall industry, and the project management
profession. Thus project management also calls for keen interpersonal skills, such as
being able to act as a leader, to communicate effectively, to negotiate and manage con-
flict, to solve problems, to influence the organization, and to motivate people.
Leadership is a broad term encompassing many areas related to working with oth-
ers. To lead means, among other things, to establish direction, align people with that
direction, motivate them to work hard and do their best, and inspire them to succeed,
often by example.
Communicating
Communicating—exchanging information—is something we all do every day, but it
is also something most of us do not do well. Communication has many dimensions.
It can be written or oral, involve speaking and listening, be internal or external, formal
or informal, vertical or horizontal. Furthermore, it involves choosing the appropriate
media, establishing a clear and precise writing style, developing good presentation tech-
niques, and learning how to successfully run and manage a meeting.
Negotiating
Negotiation involves coming to terms and reaching an agreement. Negotiating is a con-
stant part of project management. The three key elements of any project—scope, cost,
and time—are subject to continual negotiation, as are contracts, personnel assignments,
and resource allocation.
Problem Solving
There are two aspects of problem solving: problem definition and decision-making.
Defining a problem sounds trivial and obvious, but correctly defining a problem means
the difference between solving the real problem or solving something else. Defining a
problem correctly means distinguishing between causes and symptoms, and it involves
gathering information and problem finding.
Decision-making involves analysis of the problem, which leads to possible solutions
and choosing from among them. It is important to note that all decisions have time
restrictions; thus it is rarely possible to find and collect all relevant information. Deci-
sion-making rarely results in optimal decisions. Instead, due to time limitations and
limits to human processing, decision-making often results in “satisficing”—choosing
the best alternative available as soon as it is found.
Motivating People
Project managers need to determine how to get other people to do project tasks and to
do them well. Motivating team members to succeed means energizing them to achieve
at high levels and to overcome obstacles to change. Project managers have many moti-
vational tools at their disposal, including many types of rewards and sanctions.
• The website of the Australian Bureau of Statistics’ August 2016 Census had so
many site failures that the majority of Australians could not complete the Census
on the designated day, and it was offline for more than two days during the critical
data collection period (Head & Walker, 2016; Uhlmann & Doran, 2016).
• Target attempted to implement SAP into its Canadian businesses. This roll-out
was different from using custom supply chain software it used in the United
States. Unfortunately, the implementation was so bad (e.g., having to manually
enter data for 75,000 products) that it contributed to Target’s decision to close
all 133 Canadian stores, leaving nearly 18,000 employees out of work as of April
12, 2015 ( Jackson, 2016).
• In 2012, the U.S. Air Force terminated a US$1.03 billion, seven-year project
that was intended to replace about 240 outdated systems with a single integrated
enterprise resource planning system to focus on the air force’s global supply chain
(Charette, 2013).
Having established that many projects in modern organizations fail, our next step
is to attempt to identify why this happens.
Project Success
What is project success? Project success is often measured using time, cost, scope, and
quality, as well as the achievement of the project’s objectives, but project managers have
to work with key stakeholders to determine what success means for each individual
project. What can be done to make a project a success? Although the answer to this
question will be addressed throughout this textbook, simply put, good project man-
agement practices can enable companies to reduce both the causes of project failures
and, ultimately, the failures themselves. The Standish Group examined project success
factors and identified management support, user involvement, clear business objectives,
optimization, and skilled resources as the primary factors influencing project success
(see Figure 1.19)
The following are some examples of how project management tech-
niques can lead to project success:
knowledge area is covered in the textbook. A filled in circle designates coverage in the
current chapter.
In this chapter, we have provided an introduction to project management and intro-
duced topics related to the role of the project manager and core competences. We have
also discussed the distinction between project phases, the project life cycle, project
processes, and project management process groups. Figure 1.20 identifies this coverage
and illustrates the coverage in upcoming chapters as well.
Figure 1.20 Chapter 1 and PMBOK coverage
Key: 𐩒 where the material is covered in the textbook; ⚫ current chapter coverage
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Textbook Chapters -------------->
PMBOK Knowledge Area
1 Introduction
1.2 Foundational Elements ⚫ 𐩒
2 The Environment in Which Projects Operate
2.2 Enterprise Environmental Factors 𐩒
2.2 Organizational Process Assets 𐩒
2.3 Organizational Systems 𐩒
3 The Role of the Project Manager
3.2 Definition of a Project Manager ⚫
3.3
The Project Manager’s Sphere of
Influence
𐩒
3.4 Project Manager Competences ⚫ 𐩒 𐩒
3.5 Performing Integration 𐩒
4 Project Integration Management
4.1 Develop Project Charter 𐩒
4.2 Develop Project Management Plan 𐩒
4.3 Direct and Manage Project Work 𐩒
4.4 Manage Project Knowledge 𐩒
4.5 Monitor and Control Project Work 𐩒 𐩒
4.6 Perform Integrated Change Control 𐩒
4.7 Close Project or Phase 𐩒 𐩒
5 Project Scope Management
5.1 Plan Scope Management 𐩒
5.2 Collect Requirements 𐩒
5.3 Define Scope 𐩒
5.4 Create WBS 𐩒 𐩒
5.5 Validate Scope 𐩒
5.6 Control Scope 𐩒 𐩒
6 Project Schedule Management
6.1 Plan Schedule Management 𐩒
6.2 Define Activities 𐩒
Chapter Summary
Understand the defining characteristics of a project. related to the ever-increasing complexity of software
A project is “a planned undertaking of related activ- and the fact that methodologies for IS projects are in
ities to achieve a unique outcome that has a spec- constant flux.
ified duration.” In organizations, individual projects
are grouped together as programs. A portfolio may Understand project management and its elements.
include a variety of projects or programs. Projects, Project management is defined as “the application
programs, and portfolios are executed to meet a spe- of knowledge, skills, tools, and techniques to project
cific need for a stakeholder or group of stakeholders. A activities in order to meet project requirements.” A
project sponsor is a member of the organization who project typically follows a project life cycle, from con-
is responsible for the high-level support of the project. ception to completion. During the different phases of
Business projects frequently have an assigned project a project life cycle, different processes are performed.
manager. Two primary reasons for undertaking infor- Based on their purposes, these processes are grouped
mation systems projects are to solve business prob- into initiating, planning, executing, monitoring and
lems or to take advantage of business opportunities. controlling, and closing process groups. The processes
can also be categorized as belonging to one of ten key
Explain what differentiates IS projects from non-IS knowledge areas. The history of project management
projects. IS projects differ from more traditional can be traced as far back as the building of the great
projects in at least seven ways, with the first of these pyramids. Project management tools that have been
differences resulting from the rapid evolution of developed include the Gantt chart, the critical path
information technology. Because of the ever-chang- method, and three-point estimates. Highly dynamic
ing nature of information technology, new devel- environments and ever-increasing uncertainty has
opments are constantly being introduced, and firms given rise to agile approaches for various projects.
must quickly decide whether to invest in them or risk Project management software such as Microsoft Proj-
losing a potential competitive advantage. A second ect is commonly used by organizations for managing
difference is the difficulty associated with hiring expe- information system projects.
rienced IS personnel. As personnel gain IS-specific
project experience, they are quickly recruited by other Understand the skills of a successful project manager.
organizations. A third difference involves manag- Successful project managers possess a multitude of
ing the end users’ involvement during the require- skills related to three key areas— technical project
ments-analysis phase of systems development. The management skills, strategic and business manage-
project team must be aware that people with widely ment skills, and leadership. Technical skills and proj-
varied levels of technical proficiency are likely to use ect management skills will allow you to effectively
an information system. A fourth difference is the need communicate with your team members, find solu-
for IS project team members to be aware of the many tions to obstacles encountered during a project, and
different development methodologies. These meth- successfully complete a project. Project management,
odologies include the systems development life cycle though highly specialized, is still a form of manage-
(SDLC) and agile methodologies. A fifth unique ment; thus strategic and business management skills
aspect differentiating IS projects from many other apply much as they would to any other form of man-
types of projects is that the attempted solutions may agement. A project manager not only leads the project
never have been tried before. A sixth unique aspect of team and communicates with the project sponsor and
IS projects that creates a level of complexity beyond other stakeholders, but also serves a critical role in
non-IS projects is related to managing project scope. communicating with other members of the organi-
Project scope, which involves the planned definition zation, the overall industry, and the project manage-
and size of a project, is likely to change in many proj- ment profession. Thus project management also calls
ects. A seventh unique feature of IS projects is that for keen interpersonal skills.
the technologies involved in projects may change
during the course of the project, presenting a moving Understand reasons for project failure and project
target for the project team. Other unique aspects are success. Project failures can be defined in terms of
projects that finish over budget, projects that are not the causes of project failures and, ultimately, the fail-
completed on time, and projects that may have been ures themselves. Project success can be defined as the
finished on time and budget but failed to deliver a degree to which project objectives have been achieved
system that met stakeholder expectations. Leading
on time, within budget, and with the agreed upon
causes of project failure include incomplete require-
quality and scope. The primary factors influencing
ments, lack of user involvement, lack or resources,
unrealistic expectations, lack of executive support, project success are management support, user involve-
and communication failure. Good project manage- ment, a clear statement of objectives, optimization,
ment practices can enable companies to reduce both and skilled resources.
Match each of the key terms with the definition that best fits it.
1. A bar chart showing the start and end dates for the activities of a project.
2. A group of projects or programs (which may not be directly related) pursued to reach strategic objectives.
3. A listing of the activities necessary for the completion of a project.
4. A member of the organization who is responsible for the high-level support of the project.
5. A method used for determining the sequence of task activities that directly affect the completion of a
project.
6. A person with a diverse set of skills—general management, leadership, technical, conflict management,
and customer relationship management—who is responsible for managing a project as it goes through
its individual phases from concept to completion.
7. A planned undertaking of related activities to achieve a unique outcome that has a specified duration.
8. A repository of project management practices that are generally recognized as good practices.
9. A schematic display that illustrates the various tasks in a project as well as their sequential relationship.
10. A structured approach to systems development.
11. A structured process-based project management methodology providing processes, templates, and
steps.
12. A technique that averages optimistic, pessimistic, and realistic time to calculate the expected time for
a particular task.
13. An association designed to bring together project management professionals to enhance organizational
success by maturing the project management profession.
14. An individual, group, or organization that is actively involved in the project, has a vested interest in its
success, and/or has a positive or negative influence over the project and its results.
15. Expedited approaches to systems development focusing on iterative development, incremental delivery,
and frequent feedback.
16. Groups of processes performed to initiate, plan, execute, monitor and control, and close a project.
17. Related projects coordinated to harness synergies.
18. Software designed by Microsoft to help people manage projects.
19. The collection of manual and software tools used to support all aspects of managing a project.
20. The degree to which project objectives have been achieved on time, within budget, and with the agreed
upon quality and scope.
21. The phases a project goes through from concept to completion.
22. The process used for executing the project management plan.
Review Questions
1. What is the definition of a project?
2. What are some examples of projects, and how do they differ from nonprojects?
3. What does it mean for a project to fail, and how often does this occur?
4. What are some common reasons for project failure?
5. List five unique characteristics of IS projects.
6. What is project management? What are the five project management process groups?
7. Why do organizations choose to utilize agile approaches?
8. What are four potential classifications of project management technology? Explain each one.
9. List three major historical projects that used project management processes.
10. What are the three major skills of a successful project manager? Explain each one.
Chapter Exercises
1. Visit the PMI website at [Link]. What are some of the services provided by the PMI? In one
or two paragraphs, describe some of the services offered by the institute. Using the site’s keyword
search function, perform a search for common terms such as project, project management, and project life
cycle (use quotation marks for terms consisting of multiple words). Write a one-page summary of the
information available for these topics and how managers might use this information to better manage
projects.
2. What problems can occur if a project does not have support from senior-level executives?
3. The project manager has a diverse set of skills. List some of these skills and describe a situation where
each skill would be useful.
4. Explain the two main reasons for undertaking information systems projects.
5. Using the internet, find examples of IS projects that have failed. Were these easy to find? If not, explain
some of the reasons why organizations do not publicize project failures.
6. This chapter provides several examples of how project management techniques can lead to project
success. Using the internet, find at least three other examples of project success that can be attributed
to good project management techniques and describe what the managers of those projects did well.
7. Of the unique features that make IS projects difficult to manage, which ones are most likely to prevail
in the future? Which may become less important? Why?
8. What are the project management process groups? Describe each in reference to a project that you have
recently worked on.
9. Several historically significant projects were mentioned in the chapter. Using the internet or any other
resource, find at least three other historical projects that used project management processes. Write one
paragraph for each project describing the project management processes that were used and how they
were applied.
10. Using the internet or any other resource, perform a search for “project life cycle.” Find at least three dif-
ferent project life cycles that are not information-systems related. Write a one-page summary explain-
ing the differences and similarities of the life cycles that you find.
11. Using the internet or any other resource, perform a search for “systems development life cycle.” Write
a one-page summary that outlines the similarities and differences between the systems development
life cycle (SDLC) and each of the project life cycles you summarized in the previous exercise.
develop the system using modern project manage- members to apply the materials from each chapter in
ment techniques and tools. the development of an entertainment website similar
Following each Chapter Case, we will also have to the one created by SMG for the Seattle Seahawks.
a Chapter Project that allows you and your team
References
American Management Association (2006). The Ethical Enterprise: Doing the Right Things in the Right
Ways, Today and Tomorrow. [Link]. Retrieved July 9, 2018, from [Link]
[Link]
Charette, R. N. (2013, December 6). The U.S. Air Force Explains its $1 Billion ECSS Bonfire. IEEE Spec-
trum. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
force-explains-its-billion-ecss-bonfire
CIO Magazine (2001). The Secret to Software Success. CIO Magazine. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
.[Link]/article/2441472/enterprise-software/[Link]
Davenport, C. (2016, October 27). Mozilla Announces Project Quantum, an Improved Rendering Engine
for Firefox. [Link]. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
mozilla-announces-project-quantum-improved-rendering-engine-firefox
Halvorson, B. (2017, January 5). The Gigafactory Is One Tesla Project That’s on Schedule. Car and Driver.
Retrieved July 9, 2018, from [Link]
Head, B., & Walker, D. (2016, November 1). The Enormous Cost of IT Project Failure. Intheblack. Retrieved July
4, 2018, from [Link]
Hoffman, W. (2003). Missing Links. PM Network 17(6), 50–54.
IT Cortex. (2003). Failure Causes. IT Cortex. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
Failure_Cause.htm
Jackson, B. (2016, January 25). Four IT Lessons Learned from Target Canada’s Failure as Docu-
mented by Canadian Business. [Link]. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
news/4-it-lessons-learned-from-target-canadas-failure-as-documented-by-canadian-business
Jaffe, E. (2015, October 13). From $250 Million to $6.5 Billion: The Bay Bridge Cost Overrun. Citylab.
Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
65-billion-the-baybridge-cost-overrun/410254
Korosec, K. (2017, November 14). Mozilla Brings Competition to Google Chrome with New Fire-
fox Quantum Browser. Fortune. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
mozilla-firefox-quantum-chrome
Kwak, Y. (2004). Brief History of Project Management. In Carayannis, Kwak, and Anbari (eds.), The Story of
Managing Projects. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Marr, B. (2016, September 9). Big Data in Banking: How Citibank Delivers Real Business Benefits with Its Data-First
Approach. [Link]. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
big-data-in-banking-how-citibank-delivers-real-business-benefits-with-their-data-first-approach
NASSCOM (2014). Analysis of Talent Supply and Demand. NASSCOM. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from http://
[Link]/sites/default/files/uploads/docs/ssc_council/reports/NASSCOM_Talent_Supply_and_
Demand_Analysis.pdf
Pratt, Mary K. (2017). Why IT Projects Still Fail. CIO. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
.com/article/3211485/project-management/[Link]
Project Management Institute. [Link]. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
Project Management Institute (2017). Agile Practice Guide. Newtown Square, PA: Author.
Project Management Institute (2017). PMBOK: A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (6th ed.).
Newtown Square, PA: Author.
Standish Group (1994). The CHAOS Report (1994). Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
.com/sample_research_files/chaos_report_1994.pdf
Standish Group (2014). CHAOS Report: 21st Anniversary Edition. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
.[Link]/sample_research_files/[Link]
Standish Group (2016). CHAOS Summary Report 2016. [Link]
Thibodeau, P. (2017, March 13). Pennsylvania Sues IBM Over Troubled $110M IT Upgrade. ComputerWorld.
Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
[Link]
Trent, N. (2016, November 17). Global IT Outsourcing Market 2016 Share, Trend, Segmentation and
Forecast to 2022. Marketers Media. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
-it-outsourcing-market-2016-share-trend-segmentation-and-forecast-to-2022/147354
Uhlmann, C., & Doran, M. (2016, August 14). Census 2016: Australian Bureau of Statistics Chief Stands Firm
After Website Failure. ABC News. Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
abs-working-to-rebuild-trust-after-census-failure-chief-says/7733234
Valacich, J., & Schneider, C. (2018). Information Systems Today: Managing in the Digital World (8th ed.).
Boston: Pearson.
Versel, N. (2016, November 17). Workflow Remains the Key to Health IT Project Success. MedCityNews.
Retrieved July 4, 2018, from [Link]
Wallace, L. and Keil, M. (2004). Software Project Risks and Their Effect on Outcomes. Communications of the
ACM 47(4), 68–73.