Guide to Writing Effective Book Reviews
Guide to Writing Effective Book Reviews
[Link]/galerias/doc/sitios/centroprovincialcw/bibliografia[1]._resenas.doc
The review
The provided text is a URL and does not contain translatable content.
What is a review?
Expresa los pros y los contras del libro, incluyendo puntos de vista objetivos
(based on facts) and also subjective opinions (based on feelings)
or personal impressions). Make sure to provide reasons or arguments that
support your comments.
The last paragraph of a review should clearly express your final impression of
the work and make it clear whether you would recommend it with or without any reservations.
Often, readers only read the last paragraph of a review to know which one.
it has been the critic's verdict on the work in question. Make sure that your
The review gives a clear verdict.
The book
about a study of
it shows us a survey of
describe a story of
tells the story of
contains a chapter about
includes a section about
each chapter is focused on
The book
it is written by
is illustrated by
is edited by
More vocabulary:
Really Quite
extraordinary interesting
fascinating funny
interesting unusual
Absolutely Rather
More vocabulary:
Despite...
Although...
On one hand... on the other
While...
Conclusion:
Articles
The provided text is a URL, which does not contain translatable content.
A. TYPES OF REVIEWS
The following guidelines are suggestions for reviewing books, but they can
adapt to also review interactive multimedia materials (for example,
CD-ROMs and software related to specific and academic purposes.
Regarding the language of your review and presentation criteria, please follow
simply the conventions available in the Style Guidelines
(see sections II.1 and II.2). As a general rule, the review should be
typed double spaced.
Review title, if needed [leave two lines and start your review]
Evaluation of the strong and weak aspects of the book. In the evaluation, it
can you provide a comment on whether the book is innovative or if
simply offers known material with a new approach. It would be
Interesting that it will also be analyzed whether the author has achieved what in the
the book presents itself as the main objective.
D. EDITORIAL REVISIONS
The accepted reviews are subject to review by the Editor of.
Reviews, both regarding the size and the consistency of the format and
including the content. All changes and corrections will be sent to the
reviewers for their final approval before publication.
Please send all manuscripts of the original reviews to:
pedro@[Link]
REVIEWS
Critical reviews:
Intention:
Informative reviews:
Length: one page or one and a half pages, double spaced, letter size.
Intention:
2) Lead the review with the bibliographic information, including the number of
pages of the book
3) The name of the author of the review at the end of it. Also indicate the
institution you belong to, if applicable.
Example:
Seymour Menton
[Link]
[Link]
Job Proposal 2
Develop a textual outline to organize the order of the review and the
hierarchy of the ideas to be developed.
Choose an original title (Although generally this title is decided later on)
of the completion of the work).
Author Data.
Critical Evaluation.
RESEARCH READING
The Underlining, you must have been told countless times, is fundamental in
a study routine, since it not only helps us memorize the syllabus,
but it is tremendously useful for review. A single glance at the text gives us
it will indicate the important things. In addition, the underlining is the support.
fundamental of the summaries, which are made based on those ideas
essentials that we have highlighted. Thanks to the correct underlining we can:
1.- Knowing what things are important and what things are complementary
2.- Make good summaries and charts that help us solidify the content
3.- Get a quality review without difficulties
The underlining.
How it is done.
a) Read the text carefully as many times as necessary to understand it
good.
b) The words that give us the most ideas are highlighted in each paragraph.
important. They are usually names or verbs.
c) If you want to do it perfectly, use underlining with two colors: one for the
basic and another for the important but secondary.
What is it for.
The titles of works and the names of magazines and newspapers are underlined.
Likewise, any abbreviation that substitutes for a title in the
footnotes
It means saying the letter, word, or phrase with an underline to call attention.
the attention. //- M. Action y effect of underline.
The underlining focuses attention on certain parts of the work that respond to
the reader's needs regarding it; whether it be comprehension and the
study of the whole and its subsequent critical analysis, whether to extract some
an aspect that has attracted attention, either negatively or positively.
When we underline the most important parts of a text or the main ideas,
this makes it easier for us to study and motivates us to continue the reading process,
we pay more attention to the issue and it minimizes our time when doing
reviews.
How is it done?
a) Read the text carefully as many times as necessary to understand it
good.
b) The words that give us the main ideas are underlined in each paragraph.
important. They are usually nouns or verbs.
c) If you want to do it perfectly, use underlining with two colors: one for the
basic and another for the important but secondary.
What is it for.
Summarizing means reducing a text while keeping the essential and removing the less important.
important.
To summarize.
Utilization.
The summary: it is one of the most important and key activities within
study. You can do it after having done the underlining and
after having studied the topic, lesson, or text. You have to try
do it without looking back at what you have read, and if you do, as little as possible. This
the summary should be brief but complete with the fundamental ideas and
using your own vocabulary and sentence structuring.
Written in a personal form. You have to use linking particles between the
different paragraphs that produce the logical blazon among them. It is evident
that a good summary depends greatly on the understanding of the text and of the
times you have read it (three are recommended; one fast, another slow with
underlining and another slower one with memorization and analysis.
The summary is used to synthesize the content of a text that must then be
to comment or study. It facilitates better study of the lesson and its understanding and
it also facilitates concentration while you study. With a good set of
summaries of the different lessons you can do a final review very
positive of what you have studied.
The summary is a synthesis of the content of the manuscript, and provides...
Concise and direct enough information for the reader to find out about the
purpose and the results of the research being reported. Nothing of
no extras or embellishments: only the facts, and in less than 960 characters. The summary.
it must include the following specific information:
It is the abbreviated text of a work using the same technology of the author.
respecting the structure and content. There is no rule regarding the
percentage of the text that should be summarized, but must not exceed the content
of the summary of 10% of the original text.
The summary is a synthesis of the final research report that highlights its
highlighted points. It is the exact and abbreviated representation of the document,
without any interpretation included. All the information it contains
the final report must be included in the summary.
The summary consists of obtaining from the study of a text an exposition.
synthesized that allows us to handle the information in a condensed form
valuable contained in a book or in a chapter of a book. The information is
register in Summary Sheets, special for the case, and they prevent us from the
cumbersome handling of
It is the abbreviated text of a work using the same technology of the author
respecting the essential structure and content, but using other
words different from those of the original work's author. There is also no standard
that determines the percentage of the text that is abbreviated, but never the synthesized.
will be more than 10% of the primary text.
f. Inv. Reasoning that goes from the simple to the compound. // Exposition that
gathers the different elements of a set: to synthesize some
discussions. // Composition of a body or a set based on its
separated elements. Chem. Artificial formation of a compound body
through the combination of sus elements.
Phrase that, mimicking another known one in its structure, is formulated with words.
different.
The authority you cite is communicated to the final reader of the paragraph that
It is paraphrasing. The paternal and maternal last names are noted in parentheses.
by the author, a comma, and the year of publication of the work
The outline is a technique that we have really forgotten about but it provides
a lot of play. It is not a simple technique as it directly depends on
how the underlining and reading were carried out.
A scheme must present the central ideas of the text, highlighted with
clarity. It should present the structure of the text in a simple and logical way. It must have
a clean and clear presentation. The outline highlights the points
main points of the text and the subsections that you consider of interest. They are used
signs to highlight ideas, underlining, uppercase and lowercase letters, colors and
different types of letters. Write it in concise terms.
To work on the outline, it starts from the analytical reading of a text and its
posterior underlined. Start separating each content with dots, dashes, and
underlined. See if what you have written expresses the complete idea of the text without
leave you fundamental data. You can use capital letters to indicate the
fundamental sections and lowercase for important elements
what is in them.
The scheme is written all together and should be attempted to take up the least.
possible space. There are no links between ideas, but rather, at times,
arrows. Words without their own content from the text should not be written.
we analyze.
The schema is like a summary but more schematic, simple, and clear.
With a single glance, we can perceive the information that
contains the studied text.
- Underline the words or phrases that highlight those ideas. Underline over
all the keywords.
Note in the margin the central idea of the text and the different paragraphs.
From these activities make the outline of the text, with the front,
expanding it with further readings if necessary.
On the other hand, the synoptic chart is a variant of the diagram that mainly
It will be used when there are very specific data such as dates, names,
quantities and when a text talks about the same elements but in different
contextualizations. Its technique is the same as that of the scheme but for its
A table is created with the necessary entries.
Sketch. Graphic representation of the subject being researched, totally
broken down, the outline represents the structure of the research and can
to be considered as the tentative index in scientific production.
It is a visual record that represents the structure of the research, for the
gathering of information for the writing of the document
It is the arrangement of the probable parts in which the study will have to be divided.
work; represents, then, its structure or formal skeleton.
It is worth noting that the initial scheme is developed after having carried out
a first informative reading of the available materials; it should be based on,
logically, in the best information that is available at hand at first
moment. In no way should it propose the achievement of goals or tasks
of research that are known to be unlikely or useless from the outset.
The importance of the description within the work plan lies in that when
carrying it out allows us to confirm our ideas or modify them, because in the
pure scheme we will only see the abstraction and it always turns out perfect.
Similarly, the description also helps us see if each one of the
parts (chapters and sections) of our scheme follow a sequence
logic.
The main body or trunk of the article describes the theoretical procedures or
experimental. This description must contain enough detail for it to
A reader who knows the field can fully understand the procedure.
followed in the investigation
The reviewer does not assume responsibility for the evaluation of the work,
it only characterizes the critical review, which can be objective or
subjective. The reviewer evaluates the work according to values, norms and
procedures that will allow it to be rationally compared with other texts.
Expository.- It will be one that in two or three pages informs what it is about.
book; what it says about the matter, on which it is based, how it was made, not who
They did it.
Critique.- Critique of the summary exposition of the read book, is added to the comment.
from the same by recording the trials that have arisen from the reading and that
represent a valuation based on the book itself or in comparison with
other books.
The foundation of all research is the theoretical framework that is obtained from
based on bibliographic sources, so it is essential to establish a relationship
of all the sources that were used for the study
The footnotes (which can go at the end or at the bottom of the page that
They are used to expand information on references or any other.
technical issue related to the content
They are also called reference citations or critical sections, as they facilitate the
analysis of the researcher's task; they are also referred to as footnotes
or even bibliographic notes, which is a mistake, as it is just one of the
shapes it can take.
The notes are paragraphs detached from the text of a work that provide a
clarification or an amplification of the content or they inform us of the name of a
author and the work or gives us a reference of the place where we can locate
more information.
There are various types of notes, but the most common are the following:
1.- Clarifications.
2.- Amplifying
3.- Bibliographic
4.-Cross Reference
Technical notes are clarifications made by the author regarding the text.
what has just been written. They are introduced with numbers in the relevant place, for
attract attention. In some cases, it indicates the source that was consulted; in
others, invites us to read a certain author to expand the information
on a subject. The notes also serve to clarify or expand the meaning of
a word or a phrase. An edition with footnotes is more
important that the one lacking them.
Technical notes are used in cases where one wishes to make a
additional annotation but I do not want to include it in the text, it is included
word Note followed by a number, both word and number in parentheses.
Likewise, the notes must have a consecutive number throughout the
report and at the end of the document, before the bibliography, a list is placed in
numerical order of all the notes that were included in the text, each one
with its respective clarification.
The notes of the content, which refer to the substance of the matter, in the form
incidental.
The notes from the source of information that complete the citation, providing the
necessary data to locate the origin of this.
Every time you want to make an additional note, similar to the example
previous but do not want to include it in the text, place the word Note
followed by a number, both-word and number-in parentheses
The content notes, which refer to the substance of the matter, in form
incidental.
[Link]/html/tablon/enteraT/reportajes/
study_techniques/[Link]
[Link]/vyt/[Link]
[Link]/~msanto1/lengua/[Link]
[Link]
[Link]/vyt/[Link]
Research Methodology
Deer, Pedro Alcino Bervian. Mcgraw-Hill Interamericana Publishing, SA Year
1980 Page 147
Schmelkes, Corina (1988). Manual for the presentation of project proposals and
Research reports. Mexico City. SECOND EDITION - Sixth
Reprint. Reproflo S.A. of C.V.
Summary, pp. 121.
Schmelkes, Corina (1988). Manual for the presentation of project proposals and
Research reports. Mexico City. SECOND EDITION - Sixth
Reprint. Reproflo S.A. of C.V.
Summary, pp. 121.
Schmelkes Corina, Manual for the Presentation of Preliminary Projects and Reports
Research, Oxford Publishing, Second Edition, Mexico, 1998, p. 121.
Research Methodology
Torres Xamar, Amado Luiz Cervo, Pedro Alcino Bervian. Mcgraw-Hill Publishing
Interamericana, SA 2nd edition 1983 Page 24,46
Schmelkes, Corina (1988). Manual for the presentation of project proposals and
Research reports. Mexico City. SECOND EDITION - Sixth
Reprint. Reproflo, S.A. of C.V.
Synthesis, pp. 121.
Munch Lourdes, Methods and Techniques, Editorial Trillas, First Edition, Mexico
1988, p. 147.
Schmelkes Corina, Manual for the Presentation of Preliminary Projects and Reports
of Research, Oxford Editorial, Second Edition, Mexico, 1998, p. 109.
Lic. Clemente Pérez Reyes. Writing and Research Workshop. (Page 30).
Schmelkes, Corina (1988). Manual for the presentation of preliminary projects and
research reports. Mexico City. SECOND EDITION - Sixth
Reprint. Reproflo, S.A. de C.V. The scheme or script, pp. 44
Munch Lourdes, Methods and Techniques, Trillas Publishing, First Edition, Mexico
1988, p. 142.
Schmelkes, Corina (1988). Manual for the presentation of preliminary projects and
research reports. Mexico City. SECOND EDITION - Sixth
Reprint. Reproflo, S.A. de C.V. The bibliographic review, pp. 183
Munch Lourdes, Methods and Techniques, Editorial Trillas, First Edition, Mexico
1988, p. 148.
Schmelkes Corina. Manual for the presentation of preliminary projects and reports
of research. (P. 111).
Schmelkes Corina, Manual for the Presentation of Preliminary Projects and Reports
of Research, Oxford Editorial, Second Edition, Mexico, 1998, p. 111.
Example of reviews:
See:
[Link]
The provided text is a URL and does not contain translatable content.
The provided text is a URL and does not contain translatable content.
In this publication prepared by the WHO, UNICEF, and the Advisory Group
International guidelines on vitamin A (GCIVA) are presented.
they update and expand on those published on the subject in 1998.
Finally, the operational aspects are addressed in an illustrative and engaging way.
of monitoring and evaluation.
In 30 pages, the reader will be able to find this information that will facilitate the
people involved in the prevention and treatment of this deficiency
vitaminic to adopt the guidelines presented here to its conditions
specific and evaluate carefully their application and effects.
[Link]
Book reviews
The convergence point of all of them lies in the description of the new
qualities of information as a means of communication, and its action
catalytic in the practice of the scientific-informative activity itself. The wide
variety of topics covered in the manual and the breadth with which they are
they address, reminding one of the valuable work of A.I. Mijailov. "Fundamentals of the
"computer science" although of course, with a greater level of analysis and of
news in this case.
The 66 articles are grouped into eight chapters that address the aspects
general ones that are related below.
Regarding the usefulness of the manual, it is also important to warn that the
information professional who decides to use it as a consultation medium and
reference, will ultimately be obliged in detail due to the interesting nature of its
content.
The provided text is a URL and does not contain translatable text.
SUMMARY
Scientific and technical information is an essential resource for
development of every modern nation, but its acquisition proves very
expensive and a country like ours has to seek all ways of
that provides for obtaining it with the least expenditure and in the shortest time
deadline. Every year, numerous Cuban specialists linked to the
public health sphere attend international congresses that
celebrated in our country or abroad. But the updated information
to which participants in these events generally have access
it is not spread. If those who have the opportunity to attend those
In meetings, they will be asked to write a summary of the most important points.
the proposals presented, it would be possible to widely and quickly disclose
time (4 to 6 months) the knowledge and experiences gained there by
them. The creation of a publishing series of this type, with short print runs and
an agile editing and printing process would make it accessible to everyone
interested parties valuable information due to its relevance, what could be
to constitute a new informational resource for biomedical information, and
that would allow to unveil a fragment of what is known today in the
world of scientific-technical information as 'gray literature'. A
A tangible example of the feasibility of this publishing project is the book
Advances in organ and tissue transplantation, published by the Publisher
Medical Sciences.
One of the decisive aspects to achieve the goal of converting Cuba into
a world medical powerhouse in a short time is to retain its scientists
the researchers updated on everything related to advancements and achievements of
Science and technology in the field of biomedicine.
This type of document and other similar ones are what currently in the
Scientific-informative activity is referred to as "grey literature". In a brief
note appeared in the Spanish Journal of Scientific Documentation expresses
regarding this:
The term 'grey literature' is used for those documents that are not
spread through the normal channels, thus remaining ignored by most of
the possible users; this is the case of technical research reports,
the doctoral theses, some conferences and official documents, etc.
databases and conventional abstract repositories collect a
very limited amount of this type of literature and as a result it is made
extremely difficult to locate and obtain it.2
According to inaccurate data, between 1988 and 1990 more than 106 scientists and
Cuban researchers from six randomly selected specialties (pediatrics,
internal medicine, cardiology, geriatrics, endocrinology, and surgery) attended to
different international scientific meetings held outside of our
country (congresses, symposia, conferences events etcetera).
Approximately one third of the attendees participated in events
related to cardiology(39). Of the selected specialties the
the field with the least participation was geriatrics (6), a specialty to which the country
it needs to give a strong boost due to the growing longevity that is already reaching
our population (table 1).
I do not have data regarding the dissemination that the information had in the country.
collected by the attendees of those meetings. But it is reasonable to assume that it was
very limited: maybe some conferences, some articles in publications
national, references in some work, etc.
A VALID EXAMPLE
In September 1989, the original was received at the Medical Sciences Publishing House.
a small book, with the explicit recommendation from the management of the
MINSAP, to proceed with its prompt publication. It was about Advances in the
organ and tissue transplantation, by Sergio Arce Bustabab, immunological and
Full researcher at the Institute of Nephrology.
In the introductory part of his review, he clarifies how he conceived this task of
diffusion and the method he followed:
The editorial processing of this title had aspects of great interest. It was about
by all means that its structure and design maintained whatever was
possible the characteristics of exposition and presentation that the author gave to his
conferences, with the aim of allowing the reader, without great effort, to grasp the
essential of each aspect addressed.
Fortunately, everything favored his passage through the editorial process and of
printing and could be presented at the International Fair of Havana
carried out in February 1990: only 5 months were needed for the
the project will materialize.
If we take into account everything that has been presented so far, it is not difficult to assess the
importance that creating a
editorial series in which reviews of the most important could be published
scientific events in which our specialists participate.
Annually, the events of greatest interest to the country would be selected and
they would publish the reviews of these in the shortest time possible, never exceeding
at 6 months (table 2). To achieve this in such a short time it would be necessary that:
1. The participant-author of the review drafted it 2 or 3 months ago.
after his return.
The original does not exceed 120 pages of text, the illustrative material is
only the essential y without complications (Illustrations
preferably in lines).
3. The editorial processing does not exceed 60 working days (2 months)
and a half).
4. The covers must be classified and the maximum length of the printed text
do not exceed 96 pages.
5. Printing should preferably be done at the CNICM printing house.
6. Its distribution should be agile, with the cooperation of the National Group.
specialty.
This type of publication will require close collaboration between the author and the
working group that was previously proposed to coordinate the series, thus
as with the editor assigned to it.
For the success of this company, it will be necessary to create a work methodology.
which must be flexible to facilitate the author's work and for processing
agile editorial.
conclusions
The publication of these reviews will allow for the implementation of a valuable
source of information to keep our updated
specialists and researchers.
2. It will facilitate access to documents that:
a) it is possible that through the normal channels I may never reach them.
b) they will have them gathered, summarized, and in Spanish.
Creating this new channel for updating information will mean giving it
maximum utilization of our limited resources; expenses
what is incurred by sending attendees to those scientific meetings
will be rewarded with the dissemination of knowledge and
experiences acquired among a larger number of professionals.
4. The CNICM would have a new marketable item or for the
management of national and international exchange.
REFERENCES
Mijailov Al, Chernii Al, Guiliarevskii RS. Fundamentals of Informatics.
Havana: Academy of Sciences of Cuba, c1974; t 1:85
2. Facilities for access to gray literature. Rev. Esp. Doc Cient 1989;
12(4):489-90.
3. Arce Bustabad S. Advances in organ and tissue transplantation. The
Havana: Ed. Medical Sciences, 1990:5-6.