CAPTCHA
Rajni Sharma Cse-2nd Sem ( m. tech)
Agenda
Definition
Background Types Applications Constructing CAPTCHAs Breaking CAPTCHAs Issues with CAPTCHAs Conclusion
Intro
CAPTCHA Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart
Invented at CMU by Luis von Ahn, Manuel
Blum, et. al
A program that is a challenge response test
to separate humans from computer programs
Generic CAPTCHAs distort letters and numbers Distorted characters are presented to user
User has to recognize the distorted letters If the guessed letters are correct, the user is
inferred to be a human and allowed access
Else, user is a bot and denied access
Humans can read the distorted and noisy text
Current OCRs cannot read them
Background
Why CAPTCHA was needed?
Sabotage of online polls
Spam emails
Abusing free online accounts Tampering with rankings on recommendation
systems (like EBay, Amazon)
Altavista first used a crude CAPTCHA in their sites Resulted in 95% spam reduction
Yahoo partnered CMU to counter these
threats in Messenger chat service.
Luis von Ahn and Manuel Blum of CMU
trademarked CAPTCHA in 2000
What is a Turing test?
Proposed by Alan Turing To test a machines level of intelligence Human judge asks questions to two participants,
one is a machine, he doesnt know which is which If judge cant tell which is the machine, the machine passes the test CAPTCHA employs a reverse Turing test, judge = CAPTCHA program, participant = user if user passes CAPTCHA, he is human if user fails, it is a machine
Types of CAPTCHAs
Text based:
Simple, normal language questions:
What is sum of three and thirty-five? If today is Saturday, what is day after tomorrow? Which of mango, table, water is a fruit?
Very effective, needs a large question bank Cognitively challenged users find it hard
Gimpy: Designed by Yahoo and CMU Picks up 10 random words from dictionary and distorts, fills with noise User has to recognize at least 3 words If user is correct, he is admitted
EZ-Gimpy: A modified version of Gimpy Yahoo used this version in Messenger Has only 1 random string of characters Not a dictionary word, so not prone to dictionary attack Not a good implementation, already broken by OCRs
MSNs Passport service CAPTCHAs:
Provided for Microsofts MSN services Use 8 characters Warping is used to distort Very strong implementation, hasnt been broken It is segmentation-resistant
Graphic based CAPTCHAs:
BONGO:
After [Link], pattern recognition expert User has to solve a pattern recognition problem Has to tell the distinct characteristic between two sets of figures Then tell to which set a given figure belongs to
PIX: Uses a large database of labelled images It shows a set of images, user has to recognize the common feature among those E.g., Pick the common characteristic among the following four pictures-----Aeroplane
Audio CAPTCHAs:
Consist of downloadable audio clip User listens and enters the spoken word
Helps visually disabled users
Below is the Googles audio enabled CAPTCHA Not popular
Applications
Protect online polls
Prevent Web registration abuse, protect
passwords from brute-force attack
Prevent comment spam and spam emails E-Ticketing, prevent scalping
Verify digitized books: reCAPTCHA
Used in Google Books Project Two words are shown, the program knows first
word If user enters first word correctly, it assumes that the second unknown word will also be entered correctly Second word becomes known
Help advance AI knowledge
CAPTCHAs are called Hard-AI problems A win-win scenario:
If CAPTCHAs are broken by a bot, a Hard-AI problem is solved If its not yet broken, then current implementation is able to withstand attacks
Thus AI knowledge is advanced if CAPTCHAs are
broken
Constructing CAPTCHAs
Things to keep in mind:
Dont store CAPTCHA solution in Web pages
metadata
A CAPTCHA is no good if it doesn't distort Need a large database of different CAPTCHA
questions
Avoid repetition of questions
CAPTCHA Logic:
Generate the question Persist the correct answer Present the question to user Evaluate answer, if incorrect, start again--
Generate a different CAPTCHA
If correct, allow access to user
Embeddable CAPTCHAs:
Available freely, just embed code into Web pages
HTML, from e.g., [Link] No maintenance
Custom CAPTCHAs:
Fits to the theme of the page Better protected from spammers
Can be written in any language Perl, .NET, ASP, JavaScript
Guidelines:
Accessibility Image security Script security Security after widespread adoption Custom implementation or a general CAPTCHA?
Breaking CAPTCHAs
Cracking CAPTCHAs through programs
Convert CAPTCHA into greyscale
Detect patterns in the image corresponding to characters Or, read session files of that user and know the CAPTCHA word
Solution: Only store a hash of the CAPTCHA word in session files
Greg Mori and Jitendra Malik have broken
text CAPTCHAs, e.g., Ez-Gimpy
To break this CAPTCHA
Segmentation: Locate possible letters in the image Construct graph of consistent letters
Find out plausible words from the graph, use scores to rank roll=11.94, profit=9.42 (better match)
Social engineering to break CAPTCHAs:
Spammer encounters a CAPTCHA That CAPTCHA is copied to another site Humans are baited, e.g., free MP3s To get those MP3s, users are told to solve the
copied CAPTCHA Solution is routed to the spammer
Solution: Fix a time-to-live period for a question
CAPTCHA cracking as a business:
Firms offer CAPTCHA cracking service in
exchange for money
Issues with CAPTCHAs
Usability issues:
W3C mandates Web to be accessible to all people Some CAPTCHAs are inaccessible to visually
impaired, cognitively challenged people
Compatibility issues:
JavaScript may need to be activated in browsers
Some may need Adobe Flash plugin installed
Summary
CAPTCHAs are an effective way to counter bots and reduce spam
They serve dual purpose help advance AI
knowledge Applications are varied from stopping bots to character recognition & pattern matching Some issues with current implementations represent challenges for future improvements
THANK YOU
